The Truth – A Book Review
My sweet wife, Booklogged, reviews books all the time on her blog, A Reader’s Journal. Quite often she gets advance reader’s copies of books about to be published. The authors and publishers are seeking feedback about the new volume. Such is the case with a new book called The Truth by
Stephen Hawley Martin. Booklogged didn’t have time to give to this one, so I’ve taken it on.
First of all the superlative nature of the title is rediculous. While there is clearly a measure of truth in the book, it can hardly support it’s claim to be THE truth.
Martin is talented, he has some very deep understanding of the nature of growth, insight and living, but he’s just another philosopher with some great ideas. Few of which appear to be his own. Rather, Hawley has stepped up to the smorgasbord of the world’s great religions and philosophies and selected a delectible here from Buddhism, a tidbit there from Hinduism, an entre’ from Christianity, a bite from the New Wave, put the ketchup of Quantum Physics on top and called the meal, a conclusive explanation of why we’re here and where we’re going.
Clearly an acolyte of Joseph Campbell, Stephen Hawley Martin operates on the premise that all religion and myth is manifestation of man’s quest to understand God. They will not accept religion as it is presented, but rather find in religion archetypical evidence of a flawed, incomplete understanding of God and his relationship to man.
Had I examined most of the world’s religions I may have come to a similar conclusion. But it would have been impossible that I came to the same one. Having, however, discovered true religion, I do not come to such a generalized, all encompassing gumbo view to explain God’s relationship to man. God has plainly revealed to man, who He is, who man is, what their relationship is and has clearly revealed His plan for our lives. This was revealed to Adam, Abraham, Moses, Isaiah, Peter, Paul, and to modern prophets such as Joseph Smith, Brigham Young and currently, Thomas S. Monson. As I am sure God reveals Himself to man, it seems to this writer, amazing that people still go to the trouble of trying to reinvent the wheel.
I enjoyed the read. I got some insights that were helpful. I was amused by how closely, Martin comes, sometimes, to seeing things correctly. I was amazed at how he thought he could use some quotations from Jesus Christ to support his claims, while utterly ignoring others, which clearly contradict his position.
Jesus Christ is the central figure in God’s Plan for the progress and salvation of man. Martin’s rejection of that notion puts his book in opposition to true Christianity. If you’re a nonbeliever, The Truth will probably lead you to a happier, more productive life. So, nonbeliever, go ahead and use it. If you are a believer, don’t waste your time, you have the privilege of feasting upon much more meaningful material.
Loading...
Interesting review. My feeling is this. If you sincerely believe you know all the answers, have no doubts about where you are headed and what our existence on earth is all about, and if you are confident you are on the right path, then there really is no need to read the book — as the reviewer says. If, however, you would like to know the conclusions someone has come to who was raised with no religious indoctrination by secular, agnostic parents, and in his twenties set out to learn the truth with an open mind, my book can save you about 30 years of time and effort. All the great religions point toward the truth, but they are products of the time and culture in which they arose.
Stephen Hawley Martin - October 6, 2008 at 9:00 am
First of all, I’m pleasantly surprised that Stephen Hawley Martin read my review! Second, let me say how impressed I am with him. He clearly has an open mind and is not overly burdened by my less than stellar review of his book.
Had he entitled the book something less absolute, I might have been more kind.
To you Stephen, might I recommend a serious examination of The Book of Mormon. When you’re finished, I’d love to discuss it with you. In light of the amazing and often profound conclusions you’ve already arrived at I think we could find a lot of common ground.
Candleman - October 8, 2008 at 11:31 am
Since I’m not planning on reading this book, tell me what is going to happen on December 21, 2012?
Framed - October 9, 2008 at 6:20 pm
The end of the World.
Candleman - October 9, 2008 at 9:36 pm
I think I’ve enjoyed the discussion as much as the review. The end of the world is coming in 2012? That’s interesting, if only because it’s so *not* unique for someone to set a specific date and then watch it pass by. Thanks for the excellent review!
Bookfool, aka Nancy - October 10, 2008 at 11:08 am
Can we put it off just a little bit longer? I don’t think I will be ready by then.
Framed - October 10, 2008 at 7:51 pm
What do you have left to do?
Candleman - October 10, 2008 at 9:43 pm